Florida Stone Crab Claws with Mustard Dipping Sauce Recipe


Treat your palate to the delightful taste of stone crab claws with dipping sauce. The stone crab claw is a hallmark of Floridian cuisine. These seafood favorites derive from a long history of fishing culture along the Gulf Coast. As a form of shellfish, the stone crab is unique for its thick and meaty claws. When cooked properly, these claws have a tender texture and rich flavor. As a result, stone crab claws have become a delicacy throughout the southern region of the United States.  

According to U.S. law, the annual harvesting season for stone crabs is from October 15 through early May. Although the demand for this delicacy remains high throughout the year, such restriction is necessary to ensure the sustainability of the stone crab population for future generations. Due to the seasonal availability, it is important to stock up on freshly harvested crab claws during the appropriate time of the year.  

Sustainable fisheries typically harvest stone crab claws by removing one claw and then returning the live animal to the ocean, thereby allowing the crab to naturally regrow its lost limb. This sustainable process makes the choicest seafood available without killing the animal, but it also means that interested consumers should act fast to get their share of crab claws before the supply runs out. Trustworthy brands such as Best Stone Crabs provide some of the best options for selecting stone crab claws for recipes and dishes.  

Along with the consumption of delicious crab meat, Floridians have also developed a culinary culture of various types of stone crab sauce. These dipping sauces range in origin from South Floridian, traditional Seminole, Caribbean, and local Everglades cuisine. Whether you are new to trying crabs or have been feasting on this delicacy for years, the right stone crab claws sauce dipping recipe can make this dish the centerpiece of your dining table.

How to Make Stone Crab Sauce? 

After obtaining a prime selection of freshly harvested crab claws, the next step is to learn how to make stone crab sauce. Choosing your signature stone crab claws sauce dipping recipe is important because this condiment is often the central feature of shellfish dishes. And in addition to shellfish courses, stone crab sauce can also complement everyday meals like burgers or chicken nuggets.  

As crab connoisseurs know, the proper way to serve stone crabs is to present them precooked and chilled. Serving stone crab claws chilled on a bed of ice helps to retain optimal flavor. Once you have placed a ramekin of stone crab sauce in the center of the ice bed, this dish becomes perfect for gatherings ranging from picnics to Super Bowl parties. Use the following inspiration to master your stone crab claws sauce dipping recipe and create a culinary tradition of your own.  

Stone Crab Mustard Dipping Sauce Recipe 

The stone crab mustard dipping sauce is the most conventional condiment to serve with this type of seafood. With this easy stone crab claws sauce dipping recipe, you can make it from scratch to ensure an abundant supply whenever you need to replenish your crab bowl. 


  • 1 cup mayonnaise 
  • 1/4 cup shredded horseradish 
  • 1/4 cup Dijon mustard 
  • 2 tsp Worcestershire sauce 
  • 1 tsp hot sauce 
  • 1 tsp lemon juice 
  • (Optional) chopped parsley or chives 


  1. In a small mixing bowl, whisk together the mayonnaise, horseradish, mustard, Worcestershire sauce, hot sauce, and lemon juice until well blended. For a creamier sauce, use an electric mixer instead of a whisk. Beat for one minute until blended.  
  2. Arrange cracked stone crab claws onto a platter of ice and lemon wedges. Pour the mustard sauce into a ramekin and serve in the center of the claws or on the side.  
  3. For optional aesthetics, garnish with chopped parsley or chives.  

Seminole Stone Crab Mustard Sauce Recipe 

The Seminole stone crab mustard sauce is a refreshing variation to the conventional mustard recipe. This stone crab claws sauce dipping recipe adds a dash of Native American flavoring and flair. While there are prepackaged sauces with the Seminole label, you can use the following technique to create scrumptious stone crab sauce from scratch.


  • 1 cup mayonnaise 
  • 4 tsp dry mustard 
  • 1/4 cup half and half (or heavy cream) 
  • 2 tsp Worcestershire sauce 
  • 1 tsp steak sauce 
  • 1 tsp lemon juice 
  • 1/2 teaspoon sriracha sauce 
  • 1 tsp Seminole swamp seasoning (combine equal parts salt, pepper, and garlic powder into a 1-ounce container, then scoop out 1 tsp to use in the stone crab sauce recipe)


  1. Pour dry mustard and Seminole swamp seasoning into a mixing bowl. 
  2. Add the mayonnaise to the bowl. Using an electric mixer, beat the concoction for one minute.  
  3. Add the Worcestershire sauce, steak sauce, cream, lemon juice, and sriracha sauce. Whisk until well blended.  
  4. Arrange cracked stone crab claws onto a platter of ice and lemon wedges. Pour the mustard sauce into a ramekin and serve in the center of the claws or on the side.  

Cracking the Stone Crab Claws 

While reviewing your stone crab claws sauce dipping recipe, you may have noticed that you should crack the crab claws before serving. Since the edible pincer claw is one of the strongest parts of the animal, this step is not optional. Fortunately, most vendors or fishmongers will crack the claws for you if you plan to eat them the same day. If you intend to wait a day or two, however, it is best to crack them on your own to ensure optimal freshness. To crack the claws, hold a medium dishtowel in your non-dominant hand. Using a heavy metal spoon in your dominant hand, whack the claw in several spots to loosen the shell. 

The Bottom Line on Stone Crab Claws Sauce Dipping Recipes 

Stone crab claws represent a cherished part of Floridian cuisine. Due to the unique method of consumption, the stone crab sauce is often the centerpiece of this seafood dish. Whether you choose traditional or specialized sauce, mastering your recipe can ensure that you enjoy a rich culinary experience every season.  


If this article has left you craving some fresh stone crab claws, we at Stone Crab Wholesale got what you need. Visit our online store and order your stone crab claws today!

Delivered right to your door. Place your stone crab order and craft your loved ones the perfect dinner.

Back to blog